Which Should I Keep?

First of all, I want to say that the value of the bag I just gave away was about $25.  I know it's not anything too fancy, but most things given away on other blogs have a value of about $30, and my blog isn't nearly as famous as theirs.  I actually bought this bag with my own money; it wasn't given to me by some company to give away.  And it actually looks pretty expensive in real life anyways.  If you don't like what I'm giving away, don't enter, simple as that.  The only reason I am addressing this is because of a rude comment I received earlier.  No need to bring more negativity in the world, my friend! :)

Anyways, I've been looking for a really nice army green jacket for ages, and I've finally found one I like...well, two actually.  I need your help deciding which one to keep!  I'm doing a terrible job of modeling with them, so just bear with me!

This one of from Anthropologie, and was slightly more expensive.  It's a darker green and it's more figure flattering.  It's also a lighter weight, so I'd probably wear it alone in the fall, and layer sweaters under it in the winter.  It also has some feminine details to keep it from looking too military.

This one is from J. Crew.  It's lighter colored, but a heavier weight.  It's definitely more basic and utility looking.

Which do you like best?